I first created this Cherry Earl Grey Milk Tea on a rainy Sunday afternoon when I was craving something comforting yet special. My kitchen window was streaked with raindrops, and I found myself drawn to the bag of cherries I’d picked up at the farmers market the day before. They were so plump and vibrant that I couldn’t resist incorporating them into my afternoon tea ritual.

After several attempts (and many delicious failures), I discovered that gently simmering the cherries before adding them to the tea released their sweet-tart essence in the most beautiful way. The floral notes of Earl Grey create the perfect backdrop for cherry’s natural sweetness, while the milk brings everything together in a silky embrace. It’s become my go-to weekend indulgence and a favorite when friends drop by unexpectedly.

Why I Love This Pairing

The magic of this tea lies in the unexpected harmony between cherries and bergamot. The fruity sweetness of cherries softens Earl Grey’s sometimes assertive citrus notes, creating a balanced cup that feels both familiar and surprising.

I’ve found that using fresh cherries makes all the difference—they infuse the milk with their natural juices and create a subtle pink hue that makes this drink as beautiful as it is delicious. In my countless test batches, I’ve discovered that a brief simmer is all they need to release their flavor without becoming bitter.

What I adore most about this recipe is how it transforms ordinary tea time into something worth pausing for. It’s not complicated, but it feels special—exactly the kind of small luxury that makes an ordinary afternoon extraordinary.

What You’ll Need

Earl Grey tea: Use a quality tea bag or loose leaf; I’ve found that the bergamot notes are essential to this recipe’s character.

Fresh cherries: Sweet dark cherries work beautifully, though I’ve used rainier cherries with lovely results when they’re in season.

Milk: Any variety works wonderfully; whole milk creates the richest mouthfeel, but I often use oat milk for its natural sweetness when serving friends with dairy sensitivities.

Vanilla syrup: Homemade is lovely (I keep a bottle in my fridge), but store-bought works perfectly too. The vanilla bridges the gap between the fruit and tea.

Cinnamon stick: Optional but adds a warming depth that’s especially nice on cooler days.

Ice: Only if you’re making the iced version, which is refreshing during cherry season in summer.

Let’s Brew Some Magic

Coax Out the Cherry Essence

In a small saucepan, I gently simmer the halved cherries with just enough water to keep them from scorching. There’s something meditative about watching their bright juices seep into the water, transforming it into a vibrant ruby elixir. I use the back of my wooden spoon to gently press the cherries, helping them release more of their precious flavor.

Brew the Perfect Base

While the cherries work their magic, I brew the Earl Grey to a strength that can stand up to milk. I’ve learned through many cups that 4 minutes seems to be the sweet spot—long enough to extract the bergamot’s complexity without pulling too much tannin. The fragrance that fills my kitchen at this stage is one of my favorite parts of the process.

Create the Cherry-Infused Milk

Adding milk to the softened cherries creates a gentle infusion that carries all those fruit notes. I love watching the milk take on a subtle pink hue as it warms. The cinnamon stick, when I use it, adds a whisper of spice that complements both the cherries and the bergamot in the tea.

Bring Everything Together

Sweetening the milk mixture with vanilla syrup before combining it with the tea allows the sweetness to distribute evenly. When I pour the cherry-infused milk through a strainer into the tea, I take care to press on the cherries to extract every bit of flavor. The result is a beautiful layered drink that I stir just before enjoying.

Make It Your Own

When I have friends over for weekend brunch, I often make a more indulgent version with a splash of half-and-half and a touch more vanilla. The richness works beautifully with my favorite lemon scones.

During cherry season, I sometimes make a large batch of the cherry-infused milk and keep it refrigerated for quick iced versions throughout the week. It’s been my saving grace during afternoon gardening breaks.

Last Christmas, I created a special holiday variation by adding a star anise pod and a few crushed cardamom pods to the simmering cherries. The spiced version paired perfectly with the cookies my sister brought over.

What I’ve Learned

After making this tea countless times, I’ve discovered that the cherries need gentle heat—too hot and they’ll become bitter rather than sweet. A low simmer for just a few minutes is perfect.

Don’t rush the straining process—pressing gently on the cherries releases their essence without pushing through unwanted bits of fruit.

If you’re making the iced version, brew the tea slightly stronger than you would for hot tea, as the ice will dilute it somewhat.

For an extra-special presentation when hosting friends, I freeze a few cherries to use as beautiful, functional ice cubes that won’t water down the drink.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use frozen cherries instead of fresh? → Absolutely! I’ve made this with frozen cherries many times during winter months. No need to thaw them first; just simmer them a minute or two longer.

What if I don’t have vanilla syrup? → A teaspoon of honey or maple syrup works beautifully, though you’ll miss some of the vanilla notes. You can add a few drops of vanilla extract to compensate.

Can I make this without caffeine? → Yes! I’ve made this for my evening gatherings using decaf Earl Grey with wonderful results. You could also substitute rooibos tea for a naturally caffeine-free option.

How long does the cherry-infused milk keep? → When stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator, it stays fresh for up to 3 days. I actually think the flavor improves after the first day!

Can I use cherry juice instead of fresh cherries? → You can, though I find the depth of flavor isn’t quite the same. If using juice, reduce the amount to about 2 tablespoons and skip the simmering step.

Print