Last summer, I stumbled upon what would become one of my family’s most requested meals while trying to use up leftover roast chicken. My refrigerator was nearly empty except for some cheese and a half-used loaf of garlic bread from the previous night’s pasta dinner. What started as a simple necessity quickly became a regular in our rotation – this sandwich combines all the comfort of garlic bread with savory chicken and melty cheese that creates those irresistible cheese pulls my kids love to photograph.

The Magic of Simple Combinations

There’s something deeply satisfying about transforming leftovers into something that feels completely new. I’ve found that the key to this sandwich isn’t fancy ingredients or complicated techniques – it’s understanding how these simple flavors complement each other.

The garlic bread provides a buttery, aromatic foundation, while the chicken mixture stays moist and flavorful thanks to the mayo-mustard blend. I’ve tested this sandwich with various cheese combinations, but the mozzarella and Parmesan duo consistently delivers that perfect melt and flavor balance that keeps everyone asking for seconds.

What You’ll Need

Garlic bread: I often use store-bought for convenience, but when I have extra time, I make my own with a fresh baguette, butter, minced garlic, and herbs. The garlic flavor infuses the entire sandwich.

Cooked chicken: Leftover roasted chicken works beautifully here, but I’ve used rotisserie chicken on busy weeknights with equally delicious results. The tender texture absorbs the flavors wonderfully.

Mozzarella cheese: For that quintessential stretch when you pull the sandwich apart. I prefer low-moisture mozzarella as it melts more consistently and doesn’t make the bread soggy.

Parmesan cheese: Adds a salty, nutty depth that elevates the entire sandwich. I grate mine fresh, but pre-grated works in a pinch.

Mayonnaise: Creates a creamy base for the chicken and helps everything stay moist. I’ve tried light versions and they work fine, though traditional mayo gives the richest result.

Dijon mustard: Brings a gentle tang that cuts through the richness. Yellow mustard can substitute but lacks some of the complexity.

Salt and pepper: Simple but essential for bringing all the flavors together.

Let’s Get Cooking

Prepare Your Chicken Mixture

I start by shredding the chicken fairly fine – I find this helps distribute the flavor more evenly than larger chunks. In a bowl, I combine the chicken with mayonnaise and Dijon, stirring until everything is well-coated. This is where I taste and adjust with salt and pepper. Sometimes I add a pinch of dried herbs if they complement what was used in the original chicken preparation.

Build With Care

Assembling this sandwich is straightforward, but there’s an art to getting the proportions right. I lay out my garlic bread slices and spread the chicken mixture evenly on one piece, making sure to go right to the edges. Then comes the cheese – I sprinkle the mozzarella first, followed by the Parmesan, which creates a beautiful crust when it hits the heat.

The Golden Finish

The cooking technique makes all the difference here. I’ve found that medium heat is crucial – too hot and the garlic bread burns before the cheese melts; too low and the sandwich becomes soggy. I place the sandwich in a dry skillet (the garlic bread already has enough butter!) and press down gently with a spatula. After about 4 minutes, when the bottom is golden brown, I carefully flip it and cook the other side until the cheese has completely melted.

When photographing this for the website last month, I captured that moment when you lift one half and the cheese stretches between the pieces – my daughter calls it “the money shot” and it’s become something of a tradition to see how long we can stretch it before it breaks!

Make It Your Own

Over the countless times I’ve made this sandwich, I’ve discovered some variations worth sharing:

When my basil plant was overflowing last August, I added fresh basil leaves before grilling, which gave the sandwich a lovely Italian twist that paired beautifully with a simple tomato soup.

For my spice-loving husband, I sometimes mix a tablespoon of buffalo sauce into the chicken mixture and swap the mozzarella for pepper jack. It’s his favorite Sunday football watching lunch.

During a particularly inspiring farmers market trip, I added thin slices of ripe tomato and baby arugula after grilling, which brightened the whole sandwich with freshness and color.

What I’ve Learned

After making this sandwich for just about every friend who visits our home, I’ve gathered some helpful insights:

Let the assembled sandwich rest for 2-3 minutes before grilling. This allows the bread to slightly absorb the flavors without becoming soggy.

Freshly grated cheese makes a significant difference in melt quality. I tested pre-shredded versus freshly grated in the same sandwich (split down the middle), and my taste-testers unanimously preferred the freshly grated side.

The chicken mixture can be made a day ahead and refrigerated, which actually improves the flavor as the ingredients meld together overnight.

Don’t rush the grilling process! A slower melt at medium heat creates that perfect golden crust while ensuring the filling warms through completely.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use leftover turkey instead of chicken? → Absolutely! I made these with Thanksgiving leftovers last year, and they were a delightful change from standard turkey sandwiches.

How do I keep the bread from getting too greasy? → If your garlic bread is particularly buttery, you can lightly toast it before assembling the sandwich to create a barrier that prevents sogginess.

Can I make this in a panini press? → Yes! I’ve done this when making multiple sandwiches at once. Just be gentle with the pressure to avoid squeezing out all the filling.

Is there a way to make this ahead for a crowd? → I’ve prepared several of these for my daughter’s birthday party by assembling them ahead of time, wrapping in foil, then grilling them all at once just before serving.

What can I serve with this sandwich? → My family loves these with a simple green salad, but they also pair beautifully with tomato soup or my roasted garlic potato wedges for a more substantial meal.

Print