The gentle hum of Saturday afternoon often finds me in the kitchen, piecing together simple meals that somehow transcend their humble ingredients. This chicken salad melt sandwich was born on one such afternoon, when leftover chicken salad from Friday’s lunch met a block of forgotten cheese in my refrigerator. I remember standing by my kitchen window, wondering if the combination would work, and now it’s become one of those reliable comforts I turn to again and again.

What started as a happy accident has evolved through countless iterations at my dining table. I’ve served these melts to friends who drop by unexpectedly, to my sister who claims she “doesn’t like chicken salad” (she ate two), and even photographed them for my personal recipe journal before deciding to share them with you. There’s something magical about how the melted cheese mingles with cool, creamy chicken salad and the fresh crunch of vegetables.

Why This Combination Works

The contrast of temperatures and textures is what makes this sandwich special. Warm, toasty bread with melted cheese creates the perfect foundation for cool, creamy chicken salad. I’ve found that toasting both slices separately allows the cheese to melt completely while keeping the bread crisp—something that doesn’t happen with traditional grilled sandwich methods.

The way the warm bread slightly warms the edges of the chicken salad without heating it through creates distinct temperature zones that make each bite interesting. It’s a small detail, but one that transforms this from an ordinary sandwich into something that feels thoughtfully crafted.

What You’ll Need

Bread: Two slices; I’ve tested this with everything from basic white to hearty whole wheat. Sourdough adds a pleasant tanginess that complements the chicken salad beautifully.

Chicken salad: About 1/3 cup per sandwich; homemade is wonderful, but I’ve used store-bought in a pinch with excellent results.

Cheese: A quarter cup, grated; medium cheddar is my go-to, but provolone creates a beautiful stretch, and pepper jack adds a subtle heat that works wonderfully.

Butter: For brushing the bread; salted or unsalted both work well, depending on your preference.

Tomato: Two fresh slices; in summer I use heirlooms from my container garden, but any ripe tomato brings necessary juiciness.

Lettuce: One large leaf; I prefer butterhead for its tenderness, though romaine provides more crunch if that’s what you enjoy.

Let’s Get Cooking

Start with the base
Melt your butter in a small dish—I find the microwave quickest for this, about 15 seconds does the trick. Using a pastry brush, generously coat one side of each bread slice with the melted butter. The butter creates that golden exterior we’re looking for while adding rich flavor.

Create the melt magic
Heat a sauté pan over low heat—patience is key here. Too high and the bread browns before the cheese melts. Place both slices, butter side down, in the pan. Immediately sprinkle your grated cheese evenly between both slices. I love watching the transformation as the cheese begins to soften and melt while the bread slowly toasts to a golden hue.

Build with care
Once the bread is toasted and the cheese has melted (about 3-4 minutes in my kitchen), carefully remove both slices from the pan. Working quickly while everything is still warm, divide your chicken salad between both slices, spreading it evenly over the melted cheese.

Fresh finish
Layer your lettuce and tomato slices on one piece of bread. I find that placing tomato slices between the chicken salad and lettuce helps prevent sogginess. Gently place the second bread slice on top, cheese-side down, completing your sandwich. Cut diagonally for the most satisfying presentation—something I learned from my mother who insisted sandwiches taste better when cut this way.

Make It Your Own

When I’m craving something with a bit more complexity, I add a few thin slices of Granny Smith apple between the chicken salad and lettuce. The tartness cuts through the richness beautifully.

Last month when my neighbor brought over fresh basil from her garden, I tucked a few leaves into these sandwiches instead of lettuce, and the aromatic difference was remarkable—especially paired with provolone cheese.

For a heartier version during cooler months, I sometimes add crispy bacon that I’ve saved from breakfast. The additional smoky crunch transforms this into a more substantial meal that my husband particularly appreciates.

My Best Tips

After making this sandwich at least monthly for the past year, I’ve discovered that grating your own cheese makes a noticeable difference in how evenly it melts. Pre-shredded varieties contain anti-caking agents that can prevent that beautiful, smooth melt.

Toasting the bread on low heat takes patience but results in the perfect balance—crisp exterior with melted cheese that hasn’t become tough or stringy.

If your chicken salad is particularly wet, pat it with a paper towel before adding it to the sandwich. This small step prevents the dreaded soggy bread situation I encountered in my early attempts.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I prepare this ahead of time for lunch? → I wouldn’t recommend fully assembling this sandwich in advance as the bread will soften. Instead, I sometimes toast the bread with cheese at home, then pack the chicken salad and vegetables separately to assemble just before eating.

What type of chicken salad works best? → I’ve tried everything from classic mayo-based to Greek yogurt versions with grapes and walnuts. My preference is something not too heavily dressed with herbs like dill or tarragon.

Can I make this sandwich hot throughout? → You certainly can, though it becomes a different experience. Simply add the chicken salad on top of the melted cheese while still in the pan, top with the second slice, and heat briefly on both sides.

How do I prevent the sandwich from becoming soggy? → The key is layering properly. I always place lettuce between the tomato and bread to create a moisture barrier, and I make sure any particularly wet ingredients are patted dry.

Print