This Christmas Eve Cinnamon-Vanilla Creamy Custard Pie is a festive holiday masterpiece that combines the comforting warmth of cinnamon with the luxurious smoothness of vanilla custard. Traditionally served as part of Christmas Eve celebrations, this silky pie strikes the perfect balance between rich indulgence and delicate flavor, making it the ideal ending to your holiday feast.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• Holiday Tradition: Perfect for creating special Christmas Eve memories with a dessert that feels both nostalgic and elegant
• Make-Ahead Friendly: Can be prepared a day in advance, saving you precious time during the busy holiday season
• Simple Ingredients: Uses pantry staples you likely already have on hand during the holidays
• Crowd-Pleaser: The creamy texture and familiar flavors appeal to both adults and children alike
• Versatile: Easily customizable with different spices and toppings to suit your family’s preferences

Ingredients

• Pie Crust: Use homemade for the best flavor and texture, or substitute a high-quality store-bought crust when you’re short on time
• Whole Milk: Provides the rich base for the custard; avoid using reduced-fat alternatives as they won’t yield the same luxurious texture
• Heavy Cream: Creates an extra silky-smooth custard; half-and-half can work in a pinch but won’t be quite as decadent
• Eggs: Act as the natural thickener for the custard; room temperature eggs incorporate more easily
• Granulated Sugar: Provides the primary sweetness; can be adjusted slightly to taste
• Light Brown Sugar: Adds depth and a subtle caramel note that complements the cinnamon perfectly
• Vanilla Extract: Use pure vanilla extract for the best flavor; vanilla bean paste makes an excellent upgrade for special occasions
• Ground Cinnamon: The signature spice that gives this pie its holiday character; use freshly ground for the most vibrant flavor
• Ground Nutmeg: Optional but highly recommended for that classic custard pie flavor profile; freshly grated is best
• Salt: Enhances all the flavors and balances the sweetness; don’t skip this crucial ingredient

Variations

Maple Pecan Version

Transform this into a maple-infused delight by replacing the brown sugar with pure maple syrup and topping the finished pie with candied pecans. The maple flavor complements the cinnamon beautifully while adding a distinctive North American twist to the traditional recipe.

Citrus-Spiced Adaptation

Add a bright note to your custard by incorporating the zest of one orange or lemon into the filling mixture. This citrus addition pairs wonderfully with the warm spices and cuts through the richness of the custard, creating a more complex flavor profile.

Chocolate Marble Option

For chocolate lovers, prepare the custard as directed, then remove one cup of the mixture and whisk in 2 ounces of melted dark chocolate. Pour the vanilla custard into the crust, then swirl in the chocolate mixture before baking for an elegant marbled effect and delightful flavor contrast.

How to Make the Recipe

Step 1: Prepare the Perfect Pie Crust

If making the crust from scratch, combine flour and salt in a bowl, then cut in cold butter until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs. Add ice water gradually until the dough just comes together. Form into a disc, wrap, and chill for at least 30 minutes. Roll out the chilled dough, transfer to your pie pan, and blind bake it at 375°F with pie weights for 15 minutes, then another 5 minutes without weights until just golden.

Step 2: Create the Custard Filling

Heat the milk and cream in a saucepan until warm but not boiling. In a separate bowl, whisk together eggs, granulated sugar, brown sugar, vanilla extract, cinnamon, optional nutmeg, and salt until well combined. Gradually add the warm milk mixture to the egg mixture, whisking constantly to prevent the eggs from curdling. This tempering process is crucial for a smooth custard.

Step 3: Bake to Silky Perfection

Pour the custard mixture into the pre-baked crust and carefully transfer to a 325°F oven. Bake for 40-50 minutes until the edges are set but the center still has a slight jiggle. The custard will continue to set as it cools. Allow to cool completely at room temperature before refrigerating for at least 2 hours, or preferably overnight, for the best texture and flavor development.

Tips for Making the Recipe

• Cold Ingredients for Crust: Keep your butter and water ice-cold for the flakiest pie crust possible
• Low and Slow Baking: Custard pies benefit from lower temperatures to prevent cracking and ensure even cooking
• The Jiggle Test: The pie is done when the edges are set but the center still has a slight wobble – it will continue to set as it cools
• Water Bath Option: For extra insurance against cracks, place your pie in a water bath while baking
• Cooling Gradually: Allow the pie to cool at room temperature before refrigerating to prevent condensation on the surface
• Cinnamon Quality Matters: Use fresh, high-quality cinnamon for the most vibrant flavor – this is the star spice of the dish

How to Serve

Serve this Christmas Eve Cinnamon-Vanilla Creamy Custard Pie well-chilled with a light dusting of cinnamon sugar for a festive touch. A dollop of freshly whipped cream makes an excellent accompaniment, providing a beautiful contrast to the smooth custard. For an extra special presentation, arrange thin apple slices in a decorative pattern on top and brush with warmed apricot preserves for a glossy finish. This pie pairs beautifully with a cup of hot coffee, spiced tea, or even a small glass of dessert wine like Moscato d’Asti for a truly celebratory end to your Christmas Eve feast.

Make Ahead

This custard pie is the perfect make-ahead dessert for busy holiday entertaining. The pie crust can be prepared and blind-baked up to 2 days in advance, stored at room temperature in an airtight container. The custard filling can be mixed the night before and stored in the refrigerator – just whisk well before pouring into the crust. The fully assembled and baked pie actually benefits from being made a day ahead, as the flavors have time to deepen and the texture to set perfectly. Store the baked pie covered in the refrigerator for up to 3 days, though it’s best enjoyed within 48 hours of baking for optimal texture and flavor.

FAQs

Why did my custard pie crack on top?

Cracks typically occur when a custard pie is baked at too high a temperature or for too long. To prevent this, ensure your oven is correctly calibrated, use a water bath for gentle, even heating, and remember that the pie should still have a slight jiggle in the center when you remove it from the oven.

Can I make this pie without dairy?

Yes, this pie can be adapted for dairy-free diets. Replace the whole milk with full-fat coconut milk and the heavy cream with coconut cream. The flavor profile will change slightly, but you’ll still have a delicious custard with excellent texture.

How do I know when the custard pie is fully cooked?

The perfect custard pie should be set around the edges but still have a slight wobble in the center when gently shaken. It will continue to set as it cools. If you’re unsure, insert a thin knife about 1 inch from the edge – it should come out clean while the center remains a bit wobbly.

Can I freeze this custard pie?

Custard pies generally don’t freeze well as the texture can become grainy when thawed. This pie is best enjoyed fresh or within 2-3 days of baking, stored in the refrigerator.

Conclusion

This Christmas Eve Cinnamon-Vanilla Creamy Custard Pie captures the essence of holiday baking – warm spices, rich flavor, and the kind of creamy indulgence that makes celebrations special. With its make-ahead convenience and universal appeal, it’s bound to become a cherished part of your holiday tradition. The simple elegance of this pie speaks to what matters most during the Christmas season: creating beautiful moments and delicious memories with those you love. Give yourself the gift of this wonderful dessert this holiday season – your family and guests will be thanking you with every silky, cinnamon-scented bite.

Print